US News
ChitaChatter
Sign in

US

A federal court freezes the Army's plan to blow up 5 tons of lead azide in Iowa as Middletown waits to learn when the blast will come

An appeals court put the EPA permit on hold after the Army moved the Middletown blast to Monday. Iowa and Illinois residents fear a plume of lead dust.

By
ShareFacebookXLinkedInEmailCopy link for Instagram, TikTok, or anywhere else
A red United States Army sign for the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant stands behind a chain-link fence beside orange traffic barrels and a yellow excavator in Middletown

Nearly 5 tons of a decaying explosive were still sitting in bunkers at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant on Saturday. Nobody in the small town of Middletown could say for sure when it will be blown up. A federal appeals court has frozen the government permit the Army needs to destroy it. That leaves a blast first set for Friday, then pushed to Monday, in limbo.

The material is lead azide, the touchy compound that sets off the main charge inside ammunition. The Army says it found 68 drums of it, about 9,700 pounds, breaking down in March after some of the water and ethanol that kept it calm had dried up over two decades in storage. As it ages it forms crystals that can go off from a small bump or a little friction, so officials say it cannot be packed up or trucked away.

A one-sentence order

The freeze came after the Iowa Environmental Council and the Sierra Club Iowa Chapter asked the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to toss the emergency permit the Environmental Protection Agency issued on Nov. 13. The court replied with a single sentence that puts the permit on hold until it decides the groups' full request.

The groups say the agency simply took the Army's word that other options were too dangerous, without showing the public its evidence, while families got only days to prepare. Wally Taylor, legal chair of the state Sierra Club chapter, said Friday that the Army was right to wait but still plans to go ahead. "Let's do it right," he said, asking the judges to send the whole plan back for review.

Justice Department lawyers told the court they will file their opposition by Sunday. In that filing they also pointed to an EPA rule that lets a site treat hazardous waste without any permit when there is an immediate threat to people or property. Thien Chau, an attorney for the groups, called that rule an extreme last resort and urged the Army not to use it. The Army has not said whether it would move forward Monday if the freeze is still in place.

Why the Army wants to move fast

Acting Army Secretary Adam Telle has said Monday is the last safe window before a forecast cold snap that could make the drums even less stable. The plan calls for two rapid blasts inside concrete bunkers buried under earth and ringed by sand walls two stories tall. Crews would soak the ground and run water misters to keep down the dust.

In a letter to Gov. Kim Reynolds on Friday, EPA regional administrator Jim Macy said the Army studied chemical treatment, building a shell around the drums, hauling them to the plant's regular blast range and leaving them alone. He wrote that each choice carried an unacceptable chance of an accidental explosion. Lead in the air should climb for only a few hours as the plume passes, he added. An EPA field team has been sampling around Middletown since Nov. 16.

Fear of lead dust

Lead is toxic at any level and is most dangerous to young children and pregnant women. Army maps show a plume that could drift north across eastern Iowa and over the Mississippi River into western Illinois. People in the path were told to stay inside with windows closed, bring pets and livestock under cover and wash down play sets, cars and windowsills once the all clear comes.

In Middletown, home to fewer than 400 people, some residents taped their windows and photographed their foundations in case the shock wave cracks them. Others said they never got the Army's information packet. Mike Thie, who farms near Sperry, said he would move his more than 70 cows into a pole barn and hang tarps over the openings even though gaps would remain. Several eastern Iowa schools canceled classes for the original Friday date.

Leaders want answers

Reynolds switched on the state emergency operations center Friday. Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker said he pressed Telle for more data on how his state could be hit. Senator-elect Josh Turek and Governor-elect Rob Sand both called for a delay, with Sand saying Iowans deserve to know why every other option was worse. Congresswoman-elect Christina Bohannan said the Army should have dealt with the stockpile long before it decayed this far.

ShareFacebookXLinkedInEmailCopy link for Instagram, TikTok, or anywhere else

Explore more on ChitaChatter

Free guides, recipes, events and games.

More like this