Entertainment

Lone Clancy juror Michael Desronvil insists he had proof for his guilty view

Michael Desronvil, the only juror who saw Lindsay Clancy as guilty, says he had plenty of evidence but is holding some back for now.

By
ShareFacebookXLinkedInEmailCopy link for Instagram, TikTok, or anywhere else
Empty jury box chairs inside a wood-paneled courtroom

Michael Desronvil is not backing down. The only juror who refused to clear Lindsay Clancy says the evidence fully supported his belief that she is guilty.

No reasonable doubt

In a TV sit-down with host Kayleigh McEnany, Desronvil said he never had any reasonable doubt about Clancy's guilt. The other 11 jurors believed she was not criminally responsible for the deaths of her 3 children.

He insists there is plenty of proof on his side. Still, he is keeping some of it to himself. He says he wants to respect his fellow jurors and let the legal process run its course.

Tension in the jury room

Desronvil admits deliberations got heated. Little wonder there. He alone stood between the panel and a unanimous verdict through 38 hours of deliberating.

He has already rejected claims that he ignored reasonable doubt. Back in September he argued that Clancy had plotted the killings with care.

Other jurors tell a very different story. They accuse him of refusing to move even though he allegedly admitted to having doubts about the case.

What comes next

Clancy's defense says she was in the grip of postpartum psychosis when her children died. The prosecution told jurors she was fully aware of her actions.

The case is still unresolved. Earlier this month a judge turned down Clancy's bid to have the murder charges thrown out.

Desronvil's full interview was set to air on a Thursday morning news show.

Judge rejects a hearing on the juror

Clancy's lawyers have now lost a bid to put Desronvil on the spot in court. On Wednesday Judge William F. Sullivan said no to an evidentiary hearing. He is the same judge who ended the trial after jurors could not agree.

The defense wanted to question Desronvil over claims that he was dishonest on his jury questionnaire and used his phone when he should not have. Sullivan said those claims surfaced only after the mistrial. He ruled that whether the mistrial was needed depends on what was known when he made the call, so the new information does not matter.

Desronvil has pushed back on the defense since the trial ended. He has said lead defense lawyer Kevin Reddington made him a target.

Double jeopardy fight still ahead

The ruling does not end the defense push. A motion to toss the case on double jeopardy grounds is still set to be argued in November.

After the mistrial Clancy's team also asked for a not guilty verdict, arguing prosecutors never proved their case. The judge disagreed and found there was enough evidence for a "rational" jury to convict her of murder.

ShareFacebookXLinkedInEmailCopy link for Instagram, TikTok, or anywhere else

Explore more on ChitaChatter

Free guides, recipes, events and games.

More like this