Black News
ChitaChatter
Sign in

US

The first Black woman to lead New Orleans Harbor Police sent two officers onto a capsizing riverboat and then refused to leave them

Chief Melanie Montroll sent two officers onto a sinking riverboat to get life vests on passengers, then pulled survivors from the river. All 190 lived.

By
ShareFacebookXLinkedInEmailCopy link for Instagram, TikTok, or anywhere else
Harbor Police Chief Melanie Montroll in a white uniform shirt and black tie speaks into news microphones as officers and port officials stand behind her in New Orleans

Melanie Montroll never got a bite of her holiday lunch. The New Orleans Harbor Police chief had just said grace with her officers on Nov. 13 when the phone rang. Staff at the port's main office had heard a terrible scream of metal coming off the river.

A tanker heading up the Mississippi had lost control and plowed into the American Heritage, a river cruise boat tied up at the Thalia Street Wharf with 190 passengers and crew aboard. On the two-minute drive over, Montroll sent the port's 98-foot fireboat and a 50-foot police response boat onto the water in case people ended up in the river.

A call no chief wants to make

The passengers were mostly older, with an average age of 74. Some used wheelchairs or crutches. Officers, port firefighters and bystanders lifted people across a gangway that tilted a little more every minute as the boat took on water. Roughly 80 people got off that way before the walkway began tearing away from the dock.

More than 100 people were still aboard and the boat was starting to roll. Montroll then made the decision she now calls a no-win situation. She sent Sgt. Logan Tillery and Officer Devon Allen up the gangway to make sure every passenger had a life vest strapped on. They went without hesitating, she said. If people could not walk off, the next best thing was to have them ready for the water.

"We're not going to leave you," she told the two officers from the dock. "We're going to get through this."

Down the ladder under the wharf

When the American Heritage tipped onto its side, passengers in orange vests spilled into the river while others clung to the rails. Montroll had a hatch opened beneath the wharf and climbed down a ladder to pull survivors out of the murky water. Six people, her two injured officers among them, were too worn out to climb back up. She stayed at the hatch until rescue boats carried them off to the hospital.

No one died. Thirty-two people went to the hospital. Both officers have since been released and are expected to recover fully. Gov. Jeff Landry has called it a miracle on the Mississippi. Montroll credits faith along with years of drills, including a river accident exercise her department ran earlier this year.

A daughter of the force

Montroll joined the Harbor Police in 2001 and worked her way up through the ranks, including a stint as director of training. In 2022 she became the first woman and the first Black woman to lead the department in its 122-year history. Her father also wore the Harbor Police uniform and lost his life saving her brother. She says she grew up in awe of the way he carried himself.

Since the rescue she has sat down with her officers and their families for some hard talks. She tells them it was a tough call but a necessary one. "I stand before you as the chief and say I would do that again," she said. Rep. Troy Carter has praised her publicly, yet she waves off the praise. "I am not a hero. I did exactly what I was supposed to do," she said, pointing instead to the first responders, volunteers and passengers who kept their heads.

ShareFacebookXLinkedInEmailCopy link for Instagram, TikTok, or anywhere else

Explore more on ChitaChatter

Free guides, recipes, events and games.

More like this